United’s Rising Star Sesko Faces a Crucial Test as Amorim Weighs Goalkeeper Dilemma

Manchester United are set for their first Manchester Derby of the 2025/26 season this weekend against city rivals Manchester City. More than just a battle for bragging rights, the match represents a major test for manager Rúben Amorim, who must navigate difficult choices across his squad. From Benjamin Šeško’s form to the goalkeeping conundrum, Amorim’s decisions could define United’s performance on derby day.

Šeško: Searching for a Breakthrough

Life hasn’t been easy recently for 22-year-old forward Benjamin Šeško. During Slovenia’s World Cup qualifier against Switzerland, he failed to find the net in a 0–3 defeat. Across both club and country this season, goals have eluded him entirely—raising doubts over whether he can deliver under pressure.

Still, teammates believe in his potential. Fellow Slovenian Andraž Šporar backed him publicly:

“Šeško has everything it takes to be a complete striker—pace, power, football intelligence. With time, he’ll be a huge asset for Manchester United.”

United fans may take comfort in those words. After all, Šeško showed flashes of brilliance during his time at RB Leipzig, producing highlight-reel moments that caught Europe’s attention. The derby could now offer the perfect stage for him to prove his worth in a United shirt.

Goalkeeping Dilemma: Bayındır or Rams?

Up front isn’t the only concern for Amorim. The goalkeeper position remains a pressing issue. United signed young shot-stopper James Rams at the end of the transfer window, while current starter Altay Bayındır continues to divide opinion. His struggles dealing with crosses and set pieces have drawn sharp criticism.

Former Chelsea star and pundit Craig Burley didn’t mince words:

“Bayındır’s weaknesses are glaring. He might save one-on-ones, but he offers no authority on set pieces. United need someone who can command the box, and Rams could be the answer.”

Amorim now faces a tough choice: stick with the more experienced Bayındır or take a bold gamble on Rams. His decision could make the difference in United’s defensive stability against City.

Trust and Tactical Tweaks: United’s Path Forward

Despite their flaws, United are not without positives this season. Amorim’s tactical flexibility has allowed the team to adapt effectively in several matches. Against City, he may once again need to adjust his approach, seeking ways to exploit Pep Guardiola’s side.

For Šeško, patience and faith will be crucial. Only through consistent playing time and a defined role can the young striker regain confidence. In goal, meanwhile, Rams may deserve his chance—especially given United’s tradition of backing youth.

Conclusion: The Fine Margins of a Derby

The upcoming Manchester Derby is more than a clash of players; it is a test of managerial judgement. From Šeško’s redemption arc to the goalkeeper dilemma, Amorim’s every decision could shape the outcome. For United fans, this isn’t just about city pride—it is about whether their team can take another step toward revival.

As the Red Devils head to the Etihad, the question lingers: can they upset the Blue half of Manchester and spark a statement win? The stage is set, and the world will be watching.